Tonal and Beyond: The Best Smart Strength Training Equipment for 2022 | PCMag

2022-04-22 21:48:21 By : Ms. Annie Lieu

From workout mirrors to motion-tracking cameras, turn a corner of your bedroom into a home gym with the top equipment we've tested for smart strength training.

With its sophisticated form-tracking and rep-counting software, challenging on-demand and live classes, and excellent trainers, the Tempo Studio is the best smart strength training machine we've tested.

If you want to increase your strength, build muscle mass, and shed fat, a smart strength training machine can help you meet your goals right at home.

This category is fairly new, but it really started to gain traction when Tonal came on the market in 2018, effectively offering a full gym’s worth of strength training equipment—and a virtual personal trainer—in one sleek, streamlined package. Tonal is still the most recognizable name in connected strength training, but it's no longer the only one. A steady stream of competitors have hit the scene, offering variety and choice at a range of prices. 

After getting millions of people hooked on indoor cycling and running, for instance, Peloton has now jumped on the smart strength training bandwagon. The company is offering a much different (and more affordable) take on connected weight lifting with the Peloton Guide, a camera that uses computer vision to track your strength training movements.

If you're looking to kickstart or level up your at-home strength training routine, you don't need to spend a fortune on a large, heavy, expensive workout mirror (though that's certainly an option). We've tested and reviewed all of the major smart strength training products on the market and detail our favorite options here. Read on for some important factors to consider before investing.

At the most basic level, smart strength training equipment offers greater convenience, interactivity, and guidance than, say, a basic set of dumbbells. These machines connect to the internet, and most have a screen on which you can stream workouts (though more affordable options rely on your TV or phone for that functionality).

Many offer large on-demand libraries of guided classes with knowledgeable instructors, as well as customized workouts and programs based on your goals and fitness level. If you're interested in getting into a weight lifting routine but you're not sure where to start, the Tonal, or its main competitor, the Tempo Studio, can guide you. 

The Tonal uses artificial intelligence to set the weights for you in each mode, track your reps and progress in real time, and adapt its recommendations as you get stronger so you always face a challenge. The Tempo Studio works similarly, using a combination of 3D sensors and AI to suggest the appropriate weight to load onto your barbell or dumbbells for each move, count your reps, and offer real-time feedback about your form to keep you honest and safe. 

Some smart strength training machines even feature live classes with fun social features, like the ability to virtually cheer other users on, that let you feel like you're not working out alone. Tempo, for example, adds a bit of friendly competition to its workouts with in-class leaderboards that rank participants based on the total volume you lift and the reps you complete.

The most feature-rich smart strength training machines cost north of $3,000 for just the hardware, plus between around $39 and $49 per month for a class membership. That puts them out of reach for many people, but more affordable options are available.

Starting on the premium side, the Tonal costs $2,995, plus $495 for accessories and $49 per month for a class membership. The Tempo Studio is slightly less expensive at $2,495, with $39 per month for classes. These prices don't include any delivery or installation fees. 

On the more affordable side, smart workout mirrors like the aptly named Mirror and the Echelon Reflect Touch typically cost around $1,500 (without accessories), plus monthly class membership fees. They lack the advanced AI-powered virtual personal training features of the Tonal and Tempo, but they still offer a wide range of classes like strength training and yoga. All you need to follow along with the strength workouts are a few sets of dumbbells. 

Starting at $1,500, the NordicTrack Vault is the most attractive workout mirror we've seen, with one of the most sensible designs. It sports a hidden weight cabinet, so you can get the standalone unit and store your weights inside. If you don't own weights, you can get a package with all the gear you need for a few hundred dollars more.

More recently, several smart strength-training products in the sub-$500 range have hit the market, including the aforementioned Peloton Guide, the Tempo Move, and Alexa-controlled NordicTrack iSelect Adjustable Dumbbells. The Peloton Guide is a camera that connects to your TV, letting you see yourself on the screen as you follow along with the company's fitness classes. It tracks your strength training movements, gives you credit for staying active throughout each set, and gamifies the experience by awarding achievement badges based on your performance.

The Tempo Move offers a similar experience as the flagship Studio machine, but utilizes your iPhone and TV. 

We haven't tested them yet, but you can adjust the weight of the NordicTrack iSelect dumbbells between 5 and 50 pounds in 5-pound increments, with just the sound of your voice via an Alexa-enabled smart speaker (sold separately). Just say, "Alexa, set weight for deadlift," and the motorized weight selector adjusts dumbbells to your preset deadlift weight within seconds. You also can optionally pair them with an iFit class subscription, which unlocks many trainer-led strength training workouts. Adjustable dumbbells are particularly appealing, because they allow you to easily level up as your strength increases.

Smart strength training machines have their benefits, but you don't need to spend a bundle to get jacked. If you want to start incorporating weight lifting into your routine without making a significant investment, an inexpensive workout app might suit your needs. Most of these apps, including Apple Fitness+ and Openfit, offer strength training workouts you can follow when you're at the gym or just at home. Openfit even lets you turn on your camera during live workouts, so the trainer can see you and offer form corrections in real time. 

From a training perspective, there's one major difference between the Tonal and Tempo machines: The Tonal uses electromagnetic technology to simulate weights with resistance, while Tempo machines use free weights. Both systems have their pros and cons. I'm partial to old-school free weights, but there's no denying the appeal of Tonal's convenient, space-saving design. 

Each of the Tonal's arms offers up to 100 pounds of resistance, for a total of 200 pounds. The system supports more than 170 upper and lower body moves, like barbell glute bridge, goblet squat, inline chop, and standing incline press. Some of the moves on the Tonal are a bit awkward, though, and the cords can occasionally rub your arms. 

With the base Tempo Studio package, you get 90 pounds of weights, including two 7.5-pound dumbbells and 75 pounds of weight plates (four 1.25-pound red plates, four 2.5-pound yellow plates, four 5-pound gray plates, and four 10-pound blue plates), as well as clips to secure the plates to your dumbbells. Tempo also sells 25-pound weight plates that work with the system if you want to do some heavy lifting, but they cost extra. You must use Tempo's color-coded weights for the system to track your movements. The more affordable Tempo Move comes with 50 pounds of weights.

Most other smart strength training systems, including the NordicTrack Vault and Peloton Guide, work with any brand of weights. If you already have a weight rack at home, or even just some dumbbells that are collecting dust, these products can help inspire you to use your existing equipment.

The Vitruvian V-Form Trainer offers a similar electromagnetic resistance system to Tonal, but generates up to 440 pounds. We haven't yet tested the latest version, called the Vitruvian Trainer+, but the first-generation model fell short of making this list because its resistance adjustments often felt hectic and jerky, a problem I've never encountered with the Tonal. 

Whether you're working out with smart gym equipment or not, form is important. Improper form when handling heavy weights or high resistance can result in injury. That's where AI-powered form feedback comes in.

Products with form feedback, including Tonal and Tempo, can help reduce your risk of injury when you train alone. The Tempo Studio, for example, uses a 3D sensor to track 25 of your joints to compare where they are in relation with each other to determine which exercise you're doing and whether you're doing it correctly. When you do a bicep curl, for instance, your wrist point moves as you lift the weight up toward your shoulders, but your elbow point should stay in place. If the system notices your elbow point moving, it offers feedback on the screen.

I do squats all the time, so I know that my knees aren't supposed to go past my toes at any point. But I still find myself making that mistake when I start getting fatigued during a challenging workout, and Tempo calls me out for it. If you're doing something wrong, it flashes a message on the screen telling you how to correct your form. It also informs you when you correct the mistake.

In the future, I hope form feedback becomes a standard feature on connected strength training products. Regardless, when you strength train alone, you must use the utmost caution to avoid injury. Be sure to adequately warm up beforehand, don't be too proud to do the suggested modifications, and strive for proper form over speed. Remember that you're working out without the supervision of a trainer, so listen to your body and if something feels wrong, back off.

With that in mind, you can't go wrong with any of the smart strength training options we've selected here. And for connected workouts beyond strength training, check out the top smart fitness equipment we've tested overall, including everything from treadmills and bikes to rowing machines.

Sign up for Lab Report to get the latest reviews and top product advice delivered right to your inbox.

This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.

Your subscription has been confirmed. Keep an eye on your inbox!

Angela Moscaritolo is PCMag’s expert on fitness and smart home products. Teaching yoga for nearly 10 years has helped her in evaluating a range of connected health products including fitness trackers, heart rate monitors, rowers, smart scales, stationary bikes, strength training machines, treadmills, and more. Angela also tests smart home devices from her ranch in Florida, including air purifiers, kitchen appliances, and robot vacuums, just to name a few.

To date, Angela has written more than 6,000 articles and reviews for PCMag. Before coming into her analyst role in 2020, she spent eight years as a PCMag reporter covering consumer tech news. Prior to joining the PCMag team, she was a reporter for SC Magazine, focusing on hackers and computer security.

Angela is a graduate of West Virginia University's Perley Isaac Reed School of Journalism, and started her career writing for newspapers in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia.

PCMag.com is a leading authority on technology, delivering Labs-based, independent reviews of the latest products and services. Our expert industry analysis and practical solutions help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

© 1996-2022 Ziff Davis. PCMag Digital Group

PCMag, PCMag.com and PC Magazine are among the federally registered trademarks of Ziff Davis and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission. The display of third-party trademarks and trade names on this site does not necessarily indicate any affiliation or the endorsement of PCMag. If you click an affiliate link and buy a product or service, we may be paid a fee by that merchant.